YouTube TV Review – Yes…we cut the cord…

by Robb Sutton

As a good financial practice, my wife and I take a look at our subscription memberships about twice a year to see what we are using and what is a waste. As part of that review we also look at where we might be able to save some money on the services we do use every day. When we started to look at our TV service expenses…it became glaringly obvious that we were spending a lot of money for DIRECTV only to watch a couple of channels.

You have to be careful to not let the online pricing fool you. All of those “introductory” pricing plans are only good for the first 12 months and – after that – things get a little crazy. We were paying $170 a month for TV service without many of the premium channels. It was time to cut the cord and apparently we are not the only ones that have been thinking the same thing as people are flocking away from conventional TV sources.

In Q2 2019, AT&T reported a net loss of 778,000 subscribers in the “Premium TV” category, which includes its DirecTV satellite and U-verse wireline TV services. With AT&T expecting to lose that amount of subscribers plus another 300,000 to 350,000, the update to shareholders suggests the Q3 loss in the category will be between 1,078,000 and 1,128,000 subscribers. (An AT&T spokesperson confirmed to Ars that a projected loss of 1,078,000 and 1,128,000 subscribers in Q3 is accurate.)

After we decided we were definitely leaving, it was time to pick a service. We landed on YouTube TV due to channel selection, price and user interface.

YouTube TV Review – The Good

“Cutting the cord” is a funny term because we actually went from a satellite service (data beaming from the sky) to a internet based service (cord that comes straight to the house with internet) but I can see where the intent is. Let’s go over the positives and negatives of the switch and what I think as a whole after using YouTube TV for the past couple of months.

Pro Tip: Most TV services require you to sign a contract. We technically had 4 months left on ours with DIRECTV. If you tell them you are moving in with your in-laws that already have DIRECTV, they will waive the fee for ending the contract early…

YouTube TV vs. Cable/Satellite Pricing and Contracts

This one is obvious and also the reason that most switch from cable or satellite to begin with. It doesn’t take a math genius to figure out that $49.99 vs. $170.00 per month is significant. Even if you look at DIRECTV’s 12 month promotion to get a similar channel lineup, you are paying $69.99 per month. We are saving $1,440 a year in just TV service. Once I did the math it actually kind of pissed me off that we didn’t do this sooner.

Add to that…there are not contracts with YouTube TV vs. conventional cable and satellite. If you want to change services, you don’t have to lie to get out of writing a check to the company you are trying to leave. The less we have in binding contracts with service providers the better.

Tech Support and Hardware Issues

Also, as a side note…there is no hardware to return or have installed at your house. That means no longer waiting 8 hours for someone to show up at your house to diagnose issues. I can’t tell you how many times I have been sitting at the house just furious waiting for someone to come fix something “between the hours of 9 and 12” only for them to come at 4:30 without the right equipment to solve a problem. There are also no wires to run, satellites or boxes to install…all of that miscellaneous crap is gone.

YouTube TV Review - Local Channels

Channel Selection and Local Programming

It used to be that you had to really compromise on channel selection, local programming and sports to change to a streaming service. That is no longer the case. I still get my SEC network, ESPN, Fox Sports and my wife gets her trashy TV on the Bravo network. When you travel and use the phone app or web interface it will also tell you that you have entered different local zones for news and sports. All of the channels that we actually used on our satellite service were available through YouTube TV and you can even sign up for select premium channels if you want to. There was zero falloff for our watching habits once we made the switch.

YouTube TV Review - Unlimited DVR

Unlimited DVR Recording

Another great part about YouTube TV is the unlimited DVR recording. Granted…it isn’t being stored locally so you have to have an internet connection to access the content but it does allow you to record as much as you want and the interface is a lot easier to use than it was with satellite. It essentially just looks like you are browsing YouTube to access all of your recorded programs.

Up to 5 Accounts

With YouTube TV, you can create up to 5 accounts to share that creates its own DVR and suggested programming. This does a couple of things for you.

  1. I can monitor what my son is watching on TV by setting up his own account.
  2. You can share it with family members outside of the home if you need to.
  3. My wife can have her own profile as well so it is easier to find what she wants to watch vs. what I am watching.

Traveling with YouTube TV

This actually might be my favorite part of YouTube TV that I never fully got with conventional cable or satellite. YouTube TV comes with you everywhere you travel via their mobile app or web interface. All of your favorite channels and DVR recordings can be watched where every you have a data or internet connection. I travel and drive a lot so this is a big plus for me as I can stream in my car or in a hotel room with ease.

YouTube TV Review – The Bad

As with any switch there are going to be some aspects of anything that are rather annoying or require some adjustment of habits that have been formed over the years. Let’s take a look at some of the headaches that have gone along with the switch.

Is your TV ready for YouTube TV?

All of the modern TV’s down to the Walmart specials are equipped for YouTube TV these days. When we get a new TV in our house we typically do the TV rotation. The new one goes in the living room, the living room to our bedroom and then our bedroom to the guest room. That makes it so that we do have a couple of older TV’s at times that do not have the YouTube TV app installed on them. To fix that issue, we used the Roku’s and Apple TV’s we had.

We bought the Roku’s about a month before Amazon released compatibility with their Firesticks and – honestly – I might start switching them out. The Roku’s can be slow and run into buffering issues sometimes even though they are a cheap option to get up and running fast.

The native apps on the TV are typically faster and easier to use. When I get the Firestick’s in, I am hoping that is the case with those as well.

YouTube TV Review - Channels

There are no channel numbers

With YouTube TV there are no channel numbers. This creates some funny little issues. For one, you can’t just tell someone to change the channel to 42. They will have to search down the list to find the exact channel you are looking for. The other issue it creates is that there is no previous channel function if you are flipping between two games for example. You have to hit the down arrow twice to see recently viewed channels so it just adds one more step to that process.

Setting up smart remotes can be more difficult

Since you are not using physical hardware to control your TV experience, there can be more setup time and complications with remotes like the Harmony remote. The smart remotes are really setup to run individual devices all at the same time with ease and are not very good at switching through apps on a TV as that process can be different across TV brands. It is very easy for the remote to change to HDMI 3 but it is very hard for it to know to open a specific app.

You can only stream 3 devices at a time

With YouTube TV, you are only able to stream to 3 devices at a time. For our family of 3 this isn’t a big issue but if you have a larger family that likes to watch different programming all at the same time…this can be an issue. With DIRECTV we were able to watch live programming on 4 TV’s and you could watch recorded on up to 8 since it was done on local storage.

Internet and Streaming Issues

While DIRECTV wouldn’t work in really bad storms, you can still run into buffering and streaming issues with a service like YouTube TV so nothing is full proof. We have run into situations where the TV will drop down to 480 resolution or you will get the spinning ball while watching a program. We have AT&T fiber run to our house which allows for 980MB download speeds and we still run into the occasional issue.

Most of the time you are going to be running your TV’s off of Wifi so you want to make sure that you get a really good router (preferably a mesh router like this one from Amplifi) to get a 5 ghz connection to all of your devices. You might have to up your internet service to get the most out of your setup as you will be taxing your internet connection a lot more with a streaming service.

The other random issue we found with a streaming service is that there is zero way to sync the TV’s due to buffering. The only time this has become an issue is when we are trying to have multiple TV’s all play the same sports game when we are entertaining like we do for the UGA/GA Tech party. At this time, there is no way to get the TV’s to line up which ultimately leaves one group with their experience spoiled as the other room cheers that is several seconds ahead.

No Premium Sports Packages or 4k

I have one friend that still will not cut the cord because he relies heavily on NFL Sunday Ticket from DIRECTV and that is not available through YouTube TV. There are ways that you can kind of make it work by subscribing to a specific mobile package with DIRECTV but it is really complicated and not really worth it.

The other thing worth mentioning is there are currently no 4k channels or streaming with YouTube TV. The 4k was EXTREMELY limited on DIRECTV and was rarely something you wanted to watch anyway…but at least they tried to bring 3 channels of 4k programming. With YouTube TV, there is no information on when that will even be available.

Overall Review and Experience with YouTube TV

Outside of the small annoyances we have had during the switch, our overall experience with YouTube TV has been very positive. The cost savings alone are enough to put a smile on your face but when you consider that 99% of our TV watching experience was unaffected by the change…it just makes it all that much better.

Related Posts

Leave a Comment