I Unplugged My Watch for 30 Days: Apple Watch vs Going Back to Mechanical

by Robb Sutton

When I got my first Apple Watch years ago, a Series 2 or 3 I think, I ended up selling all my mechanical watches. I wore the Apple Watch so much that I didn’t feel I needed the money tied up in them. Fast forward to today and I’ve changed my mind, for a couple of reasons. There are pros and cons to going back to a mechanical watch, so let’s talk about them.

The upside of unplugging

Fewer interruptions. A big selling point of the Apple Watch is that every alert comes to your wrist: texts, email, body measurements. Even after silencing the ones you don’t need, you get interrupted a lot. I was getting pulled out of conversations, conference calls and regular work by emails and texts I didn’t need to answer in the next five minutes. Once I silenced most of them, the watch lost a lot of its value. I was using it as a regular watch anyway, so going back to mechanical wasn’t a big deal. My day became much less interrupted, and I was more efficient with email and calls because I wasn’t constantly glancing down to see what else had come in.

Something different on your wrist. Whichever Apple Watch you get, Ultra or regular, they all look the same. Change the bands all you want; you’re wearing what most people around you are wearing. I’m not a guy who dresses up much, and my wife makes fun of me because all my clothes look the same. But my wrist is the one place I like to stand out a little. The Apple Watch is a piece of tech, a computer screen, and at a fancy dinner or a wedding it isn’t something you want to stand out. A mechanical watch can set you apart, and it’s been nice to bring a little fashion into my life with chronographs and other styles I think are really cool.

From the shopCurrently Optimizing$18.45Shop →

Engineering to geek out on. Mechanical watches are engineering masterpieces in a lot of ways. If you’re a tech geek who loved the Apple Watch, you’ll probably enjoy automatic movements and chronographs too, without a screen on your wrist.

Another hobby. I said in my Casioak video that I need another hobby like I need a hole in the head, but collecting watches is a lot of fun. A lot of people who got used to wearing something on their wrist with the Apple Watch are moving into mechanical watches and enjoying both sides.

The downsides

Workouts. This is the big one. I got a cellular Apple Watch so I could run with music without carrying my phone. Obviously a mechanical watch can’t do that, so I still grab my Apple Watch Ultra for workouts. Popping in AirPods with music playing from my watch is something I can’t give up.

Health tracking means another device. I didn’t want to lose the temperature and vitals tracking, so I’ve been using an Ultrahuman ring. It tracks the same stats, and some people say a ring is more accurate because of where it sits, but my wife calls me a gangster now that I have two rings on one hand. Going mechanical means finding workarounds like this, and a lot of people won’t want to wear an extra device just to wear a mechanical watch.

Feeling like you’re missing things. This was hard to get used to. If I leave my phone in my office and walk around talking to people, nothing tells me a text or call came in. I caught myself checking my wrist for alerts that obviously weren’t there. But you shouldn’t have to answer everything within 30 seconds, and maybe we’ve conditioned ourselves to instant answers because we always have a device alerting us. Nobody is missing me in the first five minutes.

Where I ended up

I like a blend of both, each a tool for what I need at the time: a mechanical watch for daily wear, and the Apple Watch for the specific situations where I need it. I’m more efficient without a screen on my wrist, and I love the individuality and engineering of a mechanical watch.

More from the channel

Related Posts