iPad Pro M4: Powerhouse or Overpriced Overkill? My Take at Launch

by Robb Sutton

Some links below are affiliate links. If you buy through one, this site earns a commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes a verdict — here is how that works.

From my video at launch, May 2024. iPad Pro M4: https://amzn.to/3V2IJsZ · iPad Air: https://amzn.to/3JUWrYo

Apple made big updates to the iPad lineup for the first time in a long time, and in typical Tim Cook fashion called it the biggest day for iPad since its introduction. The new models look pretty cool, but I’m going to argue almost nobody is going to care.

What changed

  • iPad Air: now comes in 11 and 13-inch sizes, with the M2 processor, starting at $599.
  • iPad Pro: the M4 processor and a 1,000-nit tandem OLED screen. It’s also the thinnest Apple product ever made, thinner than any iPhone. It starts at $999 and goes up to a staggering $2,599 fully loaded.

It’s impressive to fit that much processing power and cooling into something that thin. Whether it holds up long term, we’ll see. I put my iPad through hell in industrial facilities where it gets knocked around.

From the shopPermanently in BETA$18.45Shop →

What the iPad is great at

It’s a multimedia machine: strap it to the back of a headrest to keep the kids occupied on long trips, or use it for Netflix and YouTube. It has great apps built around the Apple Pencil and the touchscreen. For me, it’s a productivity tool: I go into meetings, write everything down with the Pencil, and it syncs to my phone and laptop. No more shuffling pieces of paper that get lost.

The problem: the hardware has outrun the software

Who really needs M4 power in an iPad? iPadOS is getting really outdated. Until the iPad gets a full operating system, a $2,000-plus iPad doesn’t make much sense.

The Air is a different story. With the M2, it’s powerful enough that someone on an old iPad, even an old Pro, can justify upgrading, and for a first iPad even the base Air has plenty of performance. But the Pro? An older-generation Pro or the new Air has plenty of horsepower for 99.9% of what you do on an iPad.

That isn’t only an iPad problem, it just shows it more than any other product. Until something changes that actually needs this horsepower, possibly AI, each “best ever” model year doesn’t offer much to anyone a generation or two behind.

And these Pros are as expensive and powerful as a laptop. Everything an iPad does really well doesn’t need an M4. Everything that does need an M4, you really want a laptop for, because the iPad’s form factor and OS make those tasks harder. Apple said the launch event was edited entirely on an iPad Pro, but honestly, the last thing I want to do is edit on an iPad if I have a laptop, especially with hard drives, screens and other peripherals hooked up. It’s fine for a quick cut for TikTok, not for editing a real video.

My take

We have really expensive units that are overpowered for their best use cases. Where does the iPad Pro sit in the lineup with this much power? It almost seems like Apple is too stubborn to put touchscreens on its laptops, so it’s making the iPad Pro laptop-capable without a laptop OS. For most people, the iPad Air is the one to buy.

More from the channel

Related Posts